|
Searchlights & Signal Flares
What Can School Teach You About Writing?
August 2003
This month: Christine Falcone, Elizabeth Hannon, Claudia
Larson, Brian Kaufman, Betty Winslow, Susan Bono, Pat Rea,
Marlene Cullen and Jordan Rosenfeld
What can school teach you about writing?
What can't school
teach you about writing? We learn our alphabet and how to
write cursive; all the parts of grammar and how to construct
a well-written paragraph with a topic sentence; the best way
to take notes on large white index cards. But where do we
learn about the meat, the blood of the thing? I would give
you my skin if I could, like the rind of an orange, let you
inspect it inside and out. I would offer the long corridors
of my memory, so many openings into who I am. Where am I going
with this?
What I really want to say
is school can be a place of great learning and discovery.
I embraced my education, surrounded myself in the dim corner
of the library at my college with thick textbooks of Old English
Literature and the Romantic Poets. I spent time with Keats
and Yeats and Shelley and gleaned from them the recognition
that in life, there is so much that requires further attention.
And Dante, well Dante and his Inferno - why did Beatrice have
to look back anyway? Why couldn't she have climbed on gallantly,
chin held high, shoulders squared in a stance of triumph?
Oh Beatrice, were you meant to tell me that my past is important?
That all my experiences thus far must be acknowledged, no
matter what the cost? In A.A. they promise that if you work
the 12 steps, you will come to a place where you no longer
wish to shut the door on the past, that you will learn the
things of that old familiar haunt cannot hurt you now. Why
is my heart pounding as I write these words? Perhaps I know
that this all applies - yes, even to me. I must be fearless
about cleaning house, gutting what remains of that last dark
room where even now, so much of the meat, the blood, the guts
of my life lies waiting, gathering dust perhaps, but not disintegrating,
not diminishing, no matter how much I might like to wish them
away. So here I go again. I roll up my sleeves, push back
my hair and prepare to dig in.
Christine Falcone resides in Novato, California, with her husband and their six-month-old daughter.
She picks up her pen whenever she can put her baby down, and
sometimes holds both simultaneously.
What can school teach you about writing?
With Walt Whitman as Head
Master, school can teach the grass has ears, leaves fall in
a bow to everyone. When I write walls tumble, leaving one
brick remaining. It's the brick the revolutionary sailed through
the window in '67; students tee-peed on the lawn, administrators
looking out the windows, holding their diplomas singing, "We're
the teachers. It says right here: 'Doctor of Letters,' 'Doctor
of Science.'" And the leaves bowed first to the east, and
then south and Walt let it all go, down the river with Huck
and friends, river rats, stories told in song along the battlefront,
along the Bayou.
School of Hard Knocks teaches
me Buddha is the leaf and the bow. But how to write what is
held in the mind of a squirrel in chase after the wind? What
to take down from Sister Michael's bulletin board? A "W" for
wind, a "C" for chase but what of the mind of Buddha? I see
the "B" his belly, "H" our hunger but to write Buddha, to
call him down in word, to write the song of squirrel, the
calamity of leaves? Call in Huck Finn, call in Walt or Marie
Curie, her hands, burned by her passion, her mind Buddha in
its reach, the isotopes, the answer, the key to freedom. Mighty
Mississippi, spell it, Buddha, sing it like we did in Sister Michael's
class, "M-I-ss-I-ss-I-pp-I."
It's a wave, a river, a bow, the blowhole, my mouth with a
word my hand has hooked but what have I learned about writing?
It is an odyssey, the grand
journey. the story of Buddha under his tree, the Age of Enlightenment.
Call it down. Ask thunder and squirrel to say what they see,
a leaf, a kite, the death of one small thing, an isotope.
No grander. No smaller. No better. No
word for it!
School, the daze of it, as
Spike Lee says, dazed by life by how many alphabets I must
write before learning to spell freedom. Ask Jim that one.
Ask him about that night on the river, he and Huck safe with
the stars, they knew something then, learned a lot in one
night with the Big Dipper and a river and the black night
and a white face. Mark Twain he schooled us, he said, "You
need to know a little of this story." whether it's you and
a leaf or Buddha with a student, counting her breaths, teaching
the Master.
Teach me how to call it down,
like Mahalia Jackson. Her voice
imprisoned on a 78. My father loved you, Mahalia,
like Huck loved Jim, the power of you. I don't know how to
write it. Sister Michael, I still button vowels and consonants
one to the other. But I have never learned, despite your best
efforts, despite the certainty of the orange-red brick walls
of St. Joseph Grade School, really how to write.
Elizabeth Hannon, Santa Rosa, CA.
What can school teach you about writing?
Hmmmm..in
the past school taught me penmanship, to make those long culverts
of continuous ohs, those choppy
waves of iiiiiiis. It taught me
to love spelling and phonics. It taught me to adore grammar
and punctuation. Like my mom, I abhor those errant apostrophes
that pop up to make a single cd
a possessive cd with apostrophe
ess.
What would it teach me now?
A better question is: what do I want school to teach me?
I want it to teach me to
tunnel my way into the center of my earth without a headlamp.
I want to learn to write what I tastesmellhearfellseesmellsense.
I want to learn to find, to create new pigments to color my
writing. I was fascinated reading The Girl with a Pearl
Earring. The pigments. She ground lapis for blue. She
went to the apothecary for ocher. How did painters discover
that? I'm guessing it was the sheer drive to create, the mouth-watering
desire to express.
I want to learn to let words
drip and slip and run and jump off my fingers onto the page.
I want them to slide from my tongue to my hand. I want them
to rise from my ovaries to my fingers. I want my toes to
dictate sentences to the pen in my hand.
I want to learn to listen
with all my senses, translating the communications from the
far corners, curves of my universe.
School would tame my writing
into wildness, channel my being into a flood of words. There
would be no seam, no front nor back, no inside nor outside.
I'd learn the nutrition of
writing, the elements of a creative diet. The famine would
end.
Claudia Larson, Rohnert
Park, CA
What can school teach
you about writing?
Despite forty rejections,
I thought I'd finally found a home for my historical novel,
"The Breach." A major publisher wanted three chapters, then
the entire manuscript. But after weeks of correspondence
with the editor, the book was rejected. I was devastated.
I'd viewed the submission process as a "numbers game." If
I put the book in the mail enough times, someone would buy
it. But no one was buying. I'd spent years writing and rewriting,
and the novel was as good as it was going to get, unless I
tried something different.
So I left a thirty-year career
in restaurant management and enrolled at Colorado State University to study English Literature and Creative Writing.
I'd failed miserably at undergrad work in the sixties, but
I knew what I wanted this time. I was on a quest.
I cooked at night in my old
restaurant to keep the rent paid. Each day, I went to class
and tried not to panic. I had a lot of catching up to do.
The entire field of Literature had changed. But I kept my
focus, and discovered that a lot of the kids in class were
no more certain of why they were there than I had been, three
decades earlier.
The creative writing classes
were helpful, but I didn't stop there. I took every Literature
class I could, trying to fill the gaps in my reading, particularly
the classics. I took philosophy, and classes on myth and
religion, anything to discover new thoughts, new roads to
a single destination, the publication of my book.
I took careful notes, learning
the material, but on the borders of every page, I wrote story
ideas, notes for scenes, and ways to apply the material to
my writing. (I still use the notebooks. I have more ideas
on those pages than I could finish in a lifetime.)
It occurred to me that if
I could "argue" the class material, and if I could "play"
with it, I could be sure that I knew it. I took lines from
Shakespeare and wrote mock interviews for Wrestling Cable
shows. I used post-Marxist literary criticism to show that
John Wayne was a liberal.
Then I graduated. Three
years ended with a short walk in a cap and gown, followed
by dinner with the folks. I stayed on at the same old restaurant
as a cook. At night, I rewrote the novel (again). The rejections
piled up, more than a hundred all told, but I didn't quit.
I knew the book was good.
Last Knight Publishing, a
small press in Colorado, agreed with me. In June of 2002, I had a finished
copy of "The Breach" in hand. I don't recommend the path I
chose to everyone. (I suspect I'll be paying off the last
of my student loans from the grave.) But I'm fairly certain
that tilting at academic windmills paid off in a published
novel, and I'm grateful to have done it.
Brian Kaufman of Laporet,
CO, is the author of "The Breach." www.briankaufman.net
School can teach you the
mechanics of writing - how to use the physical tools (paper
& pen, keyboard, etc.), what words mean, how to spell
them, make them plural, how to punctuate them. School can
expose you to excellent writers and writings of the past and
to genres such as poetry that you might not tackle otherwise.
School can teach you the importance of meeting deadlines.
School can teach you how to do research.
What school can't teach you
- how to make words sing, dance, and leap off the page. Everything
that is known about everything (that's what research is for...)
What to write about. How to write in a voice that is your
very own. Why you should write at all.
Betty Winslow, Bowling
Green, Ohio, freelance writer, high school graduate, eternal student
of life
The Writing Group School
I'm listening to a Leon Russell
album-I started to say "old" Leon Russell album, but if you
even know who this guy is, you'll know why I dropped the adjective.
Yeah, yeah, songs of my youth,
and all that. I'm hard pressed to get my ears into new grooves.
Same can go for my writing.
Anyway, I'm listening to
Leon's honkytonk piano-a white trash
bluesy ruckus with a chorus of gospel beauties wailing in
the background and I am remembering how I bought the sheet
music for "Stranger in a Strange Land" and "The Ballad of
Mad Dogs and Englishmen" back when I was playing the piano,
and of course I could never "read" the loose abandon with
which he played into what was printed on the page. Alone in
my living room, I never came close.
But I am in writing groups
with the literary equivalents of Leon Russell all the time.
Sometimes, I get to call these melodic geniuses my students,
but every week they teach me something new about language
just by listening to them. I show up, they show up, we jam,
I listen. I am lucky that way, because when I am writing on
my own, I can listen to Leon howling, "Roll away the stone," and the whisper of
other writers' lush voices trailing through my thoughts. I
am caught up and carried by their gorgeous ironies, wicked
jabs, blood-freezing agonies and gleeful puns as I am searching
for my own. Writing with others I learn about what is possible
with words, and remember I am not alone.
Susan Bono is still learning
to listen in Petaluma, CA.
What Can School Teach You About Writing?
It
never occurred to me to take a writing course at Ohio State.
It couldn't have occurred to me. Hadn't I grown up with reading
and grammar and spelling? More important, wouldn't my writing
be more like Thomas Wolfe's, just pouring out. I imagined
myself placing a trunkful of writing
into the hands of a new Maxwell Perkins, Master Editor, who
would love the stuff and boil it down into a thousand pages
or so. Other times I might write like Hemingway and edit it
down, down and down myself into another Clean Well-Lighted
Place, or write like Virginia Woolf
and dream along the page or, find myself among the clever,
witty ones, Gide, Cocteau, or the cat-like Colette. In any event, I hoped
I would be more Dickens in language while Dostoevskian
in content, and yet escape the latter's awkwardness in translation
as a French friend told me who had struggled back and forth
between two versions, French and English.
With such expectations of myself I did not write until
Grace Stein called me and said "GO!" to Ari
Raysor's JC extension class for
seniors writing autobiography. Somehow I had put off writing
until I was nearly three-score-and-ten - though writing was
always my subtext.
The greatest things of Ari's
class were that there was no what the English call "side,"
and I could read them anything I wrote. Second, also psychological,
was that I entered knowing that no one could tell me what
to write. The third blessing: people seemed to like my writing.
Ari left for other parts and was
replaced by Steve Boga, also nifty.
I became serious and expanded, adding on courses at
Sonoma State with Robin Beeman
and Jonah Raskin and private with
Susan Bono and Robin. Later I joined a class with the inestimable
Richard Speaks at the JC. I had so much to learn.
From the beginning I wrote humbly and hesitantly, and
then found myself one foot and one hand at a time, beginning
to pass through the mirror, even the walls around me - my
ego, likely.
Whatever I was learning, I do not know, for I tend more
to absorb. Progress feels good, though I cannot describe it.
I thank you and salute you, my schools and teachers
and fellow travelers for whatever I may have learned.
Pat
Rea's award-winning work has appeared in The Dickens,
Tiny Lights and The Gettysburg Review. She lives
with Pierre in Cotati, CA.
School
When I was twelve years old,
I wrote a short story about a lovesick dog. It was published
in my junior high school newsletter. I was very proud. The
following year, I wrote a story about Johnny Appleseed
and won a prize, a stereo hi-fi. Inspiration can come from
unexpected sources. The Johnny Appleseed
story came from a contest sponsored by an encyclopedia company.
The lovesick dog story, well, that probably came from being
in love myself. The older generation called it puppy love.
Several years have gone by
since those two stories were written. Meanwhile, I've taken
several writing classes and have found that school, instructors
and classmates can be instrumental in supplying ideas, instruction,
and encouragement. Through school and instructors, I have
discovered resources such as magazines (The Writer, Writer's
Digest, etc.), websites, and venues (Zebulon's, Book Fairs).
And, of course, instructors and classmates are valuable resources
for critiquing and feedback.
Conversely, sometimes school
can be stifling and can kill the creative urge, especially
for young children or classes with incompetent instructors.
School can teach you to be discerning as you learn when to
ignore bad critiques and when to avoid inept teachers.
Good teachers such as Terry
Ehret, Clara Rosemarda and Susan Bono encourage students to stick with
it and try new styles of writing. Good teachers bring out
the best in their pupils, even when the students doubt their
abilities.
Marlene Cullen is transitioning from student to teacher,
having learned from both the worst and the best and knowing
when to gently push and when to allow breathing space.
Nursing school can't teach you about writing. Welding
school, Beauty School and Mechanics' training won't likely teach you about writing either. Writing
programs at least suggest they can, and I, in my very first
semester at Bennington College as a graduate student, am about to find out. The truth is, you might be
better off in nursing or welding school if you want to write,
since it's the blood, guts and structure that make a piece
of writing work.
Sure, maybe you can learn about plot arcs and character
development, about raising the stakes and unreliable narrators...but
have you been anywhere? Done anything? Do you have anything
to say? What I feel thus far about my MFA program is that
it acts as a very sturdy container around this crazy life-long
impulse of mine to write. It holds out its fat collegiate
hand and says "give me THIS, and give it me on this DATE."
In other words, school=discipline. If you already meditate
daily and make a habit of never forgetting to water your garden
or do your exercise or wash your car...you might just not
need school for writing after all. But if you want someone
to keep a steady eye on your work, pull out the squiggly little
worms of your verbosity, scrape away the fat of your grandiosity...yeah,
school for writing=good idea...
Jordan
Rosenfeld writes and procrastinates in Petaluma. If you can receive KRCB radio on your dial (90.9/91.1),
listen to her twice monthly literary radio show Word by Word
(1st and 3rd weds). Find out about some of her other doings,
including editing at www.thewritelife.com
|